Metal vs Shingle Roofs
Metal vs Shingle Roof – The Pros & Cons
Metal roofing is becoming a popular option with homeowners looking for a cost effective alternative to asphalt shingles. If you’re deliberating metal vs shingle, there’s a lot to consider. The perception is that metal roofs are more durable and lasting than shingles, but are they really cost effective? Let’s find out.
Pros and cons of metal roofing
Metal roofing is a durable material with a long lifespan, but it has advantages and disadvantages. It’s cost-effective over the life of a home, but expensive up front. Here are a few points for homeowners to consider.
Pros:
- Longevity
- Durability
- Long term cost
- Environmentally friendly
- Lower heating and cooling costs
- Lower home insurance rates.
Cons:
- Short term cost
- Difficult to repair
The allure of metal roofing is in the lifespan. While a metal roof can cost twice what a shingle roof will cost, over the course of 50 or 60 years, it costs about a third of the cost of replacing a shingle roof several times. Many homeowners make the decision based on how long they intend to keep their home. If they’re planning to sell, architectural shingles will be more cost effective.
Metal comes in a variety of styles, from the familiar large panels used primarily on commercial buildings to rectangular pieces designed to resemble shingles. Metal roofing materials are not impervious to the elements. They are prone to sun and hail damage. Repairs can be tricky and expensive. But on the whole, a metal roof is more durable and longer lasting than asphalt shingles. It’s a good choice if you plan to keep your house for a long time, or keep it in the family after you’re gone.
Pros and cons of asphalt shingles
Asphalt shingles are the most popular roofing material in the U.S., but in recent years, the cost has doubled, while the cost of metal roofing has only risen about 5%. Quality asphalt shingles will last about 24-30 years on average; less in harsh climates. You could wind up replacing a shingle roof five times over the lifespan of a single metal roof, but in the short term, it’s less expensive to install. Here’s what you need to know about asphalt shingles.
Pros:
- Short term savings
- Easy to repair
- Popular material
- More color and style choices
Cons:
- Need to replace more often
- Easily damaged by weather events
- Rising costs
Architectural shingles are an attractive and popular choice that comes in plenty of colors. While an asphalt shingle roof will not last as long as a metal roof, with regular inspection and repair, it can outlast the average lifespan and need fewer replacements. It’s a good choice if you plan to sell your house.
For most people, the choice will come down to cost (long or short term) and style. Roofing is an investment that protects your home against the elements, and the decision should be carefully considered. Your roof is intended to complement as well as protect your home.
